Unnatural Links: Understanding and Repairing Your Link Profile


Table of Contents

Navigating the complexities of SEO can often feel like solving a puzzle. Among the myriad factors that affect your site’s search engine ranking, one of the most critical yet frequently overlooked is the quality of your link profile. In this post, we’ll take a closer look at unnatural links, their impact on SEO, and how you can identify and address them to maintain a healthy link profile.

What are Unnatural Links?

Unnatural links are essentially hyperlinks that are created or placed to manipulate a website’s ranking in search engine results pages (SERPs). These types of links are considered inauthentic or artificial because they don’t arise from genuine interest, relevance, or the natural merit of the content they point to. Instead, they’re typically acquired or created solely to boost search rankings and not to provide value to web users.

Unnatural links can take various forms, including:

  • Paid Links: These are links bought in exchange for money or goods, where the primary motive is to pass PageRank and influence search engine rankings rather than to drive genuine user traffic.
  • Link Exchanges: This involves two or more parties agreeing to link to each other’s sites not for relevance or user benefit but to artificially inflate link counts.
  • Automatically Generated Links: Links created through automated tools and services for the sake of creating a large volume of backlinks without regard for the content’s quality, relevance, or the natural web ecosystem.
  • Low-Quality Directory or Bookmark Site Links: Links from directories or bookmarking sites that exist primarily for SEO manipulation rather than to serve as a useful resource for internet users.
  • Links Embedded in Spammy or Irrelevant Content: These are links that appear in poor-quality articles, comments, forum posts, or other content that is not relevant to the linked site, often with keyword-rich anchor text that doesn’t naturally fit into the context.

How Unnatural Links Affect SEO

Unnatural links can significantly impact SEO (Search Engine Optimization) in a few key ways, often leading to negative outcomes for websites that rely on these practices. Search engines like Google have sophisticated algorithms designed to identify and penalize websites engaging in manipulative link-building practices. Here’s how unnatural links can affect your website’s SEO:

Penalties and Loss of Rankings

One of the most immediate and impactful consequences of having unnatural links pointing to your site is the potential for search engine penalties. Google’s algorithms, particularly the Penguin update, are designed to identify manipulative link-building practices. Once detected, websites can face severe penalties, including a significant drop in rankings for previously well-ranking pages. In extreme cases, a site might be removed from search results entirely.

Decreased Trust and Authority

Search engines aim to provide users with the most relevant, high-quality content available. Unnatural links can signal to search engines that a site might not be trustworthy or authoritative since it appears to rely on manipulative practices to boost its visibility. This perceived lack of trust and authority can hinder a site’s ability to rank well, even for its own brand name or other non-competitive keywords.

Wasted Resources

The effort and resources spent on creating or acquiring unnatural links could be counterproductive. Instead of investing in sustainable SEO strategies like creating high-quality content and improving user experience, resources wasted on unnatural links could ultimately harm your site’s standing in search results, leading to a need for additional efforts to remove or disavow these links and recover from penalties.

Impact on Traffic

A direct consequence of lost rankings and decreased visibility in search results is a significant reduction in organic traffic. For many websites, organic search is a primary source of visitors, leads, and revenue. A drop in traffic not only affects immediate business outcomes but can also have a long-term impact on brand reputation and customer trust.

Difficulty in Recovery

Recovering from the effects of unnatural links can be a lengthy and challenging process. It involves identifying and removing or disavowing harmful links, which can be time-consuming, especially for sites with extensive link profiles. Even after taking corrective action, it may take some time for search engines to re-evaluate your site and for rankings and traffic to recover. In some cases, the damage to a site’s reputation with search engines can have lingering effects.

How To Find Unnatural Links

Here’s a systematic approach to identifying these potentially harmful links:

Use Search Console

Google’s Search Console (previously Google Webmaster Tools) is an essential starting point. It provides a list of sites that link to your web pages under the Links to Your Site section. While Search Console may not highlight which links are unnatural, it gives you a comprehensive overview of your backlink profile, allowing you to scrutinize links that look suspicious or out of place.

Leverage SEO Tools

Several third-party SEO tools can help you analyze your backlink profile more deeply. Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Moz offer features that assess the quality of backlinks, identify potentially harmful links, and even suggest links that should be removed or disavowed. These tools often provide metrics such as domain authority, spam score, or trust flow, which can help you gauge the quality of each link.

Manual Audit

While it requires a significant investment of time, conducting a manual review of your backlinks can be exceptionally rewarding. This meticulous approach entails scrutinizing each backlink listed in Google’s Search Console or sourced from other SEO tools, assessing factors such as the link’s relevance, the credibility of the source website, and the appropriateness of the link’s context. Be on the lookout for warning signs, including links originating from sites that share no commonality with your content, anchor text that seems excessively optimized, and links embedded within low-quality directories or link farms that contribute no substantial value.

Check for Paid and Reciprocal Links

Scrutinize your links for signs that they may have been paid for or are part of a reciprocal scheme. This could include links that are clearly labeled as sponsored (but not properly followed) or links from sites that have no topical relevance to yours but have a backlink pointing back to them from your site.

Seek Outdated, Irrelevant, and Low-Quality Content

Links embedded in low-quality, outdated, or irrelevant content can also be considered unnatural. Even if these links were naturally acquired, if they no longer represent the quality or focus of your site, they might be worth reviewing.

Use Google’s Disavow Tool with Caution

Once you’ve identified unnatural links, Google’s Disavow Tool allows you to ask Google to disregard these links when assessing your site. However, use this tool with caution. Incorrect use can harm your site’s performance in search results. It’s recommended to attempt to remove the links directly through outreach before resorting to disavowing them.

What To Do With Unnatural Links

Once you’ve identified unnatural links pointing to your website, taking prompt and effective action to mitigate their potential negative impact on your SEO is crucial. Here’s a step-by-step guide on what to do with these links:

Attempt to Remove the Links

Your first course of action should be to try and remove the unnatural links. This involves contacting the webmasters or site owners of the domains linking to your site unnaturally. Politely request the removal of the specific links. While this process can be time-consuming and not always successful, it’s considered a best practice and demonstrates to search engines that you are taking proactive steps to clean up your link profile.

  • Keep Records: Document your outreach efforts, including the emails sent and responses received. This information can be valuable if you need to use Google’s Disavow Tool or if you need to provide evidence of your efforts to clean up your links.

Resort to the Disavow Tool Only When Necessary

If your efforts to manually remove the links are unsuccessful or impractical (due to the sheer volume of links or unresponsive webmasters), you can use Google’s Disavow Tool. This tool allows you to ask Google to ignore specific links when assessing your site.

  • Be Cautious: It’s important to use the Disavow Tool carefully, as incorrect usage can harm your site’s SEO. Only disavow links that are unnatural and you’re unable to remove manually.
  • Create a Disavow File: This file should list the URLs or domains of the unnatural links you want Google to ignore. Follow Google’s guidelines on formatting this file correctly.

Monitor Your Backlink Profile Regularly

Regular monitoring of your backlink profile is essential for early detection of new unnatural links. Use tools like Google’s Search Console and third-party SEO tools to keep an eye on your backlinks. This ongoing vigilance helps you react quickly to any new potentially harmful links.

Focus on Building High-Quality Links

Moving forward, focus your efforts on acquiring high-quality, natural backlinks to your website. This can be achieved through creating compelling content, engaging with your community, and employing ethical SEO strategies. High-quality links not only counterbalance the negative impact of any remaining unnatural links but also strengthen your overall SEO.

Improve Your Site’s Overall SEO Health

In addition to addressing unnatural links, work on improving your site’s overall SEO health. This includes optimizing on-page content, enhancing user experience, and ensuring your website is mobile-friendly and fast-loading. A strong, well-rounded SEO strategy helps mitigate the impact of any individual negative factors.

Keep Abreast of Current SEO Practices and Rules

SEO best practices and search engine guidelines evolve continually. Staying informed about the latest recommendations from search engines like Google helps you avoid strategies that could result in unnatural links and penalties in the future.

Ensuring your website maintains a clean, penalty-free backlink profile is paramount for its long-term success in search engine rankings. If you find the process daunting or time-consuming, consider partnering with a reputable SEO service. Our SEO team can provide the expertise and support needed to identify, address, and prevent unnatural links, allowing you to focus on growing your business.

Share a post

Request a
free website audit

What to read next